Inmate Lookup Free Nationwide Inmate Search Logo


Why Did Christopher Scarver Kill Jeffrey Dahmer?

27 Jun 2023, Prisons, by

Discover the shocking truth behind the brutal murder of infamous serial killer Jeffrey Dahmer by his fellow inmate Christopher Scarver.

Why Did Christopher Scarver Kill Jeffrey Dahmer? - Inmate Lookup

Jeffrey Dahmer, known as the Milwaukee Cannibal, was one of the most notorious serial killers in modern history. His heinous crimes captured the attention of the public and the media, and his shocking death only added to the intrigue.Christopher Scarver, a fellow inmate at Columbia Correctional Institution, was the man who killed Dahmer. But why did he do it? What drove Scarver to commit such a brutal act?Let’s take a closer look at the events leading up to this tragic incident, the personalities of the men involved, and the theories surrounding the crime.

An Overview of Jeffrey Dahmer’s Crimes and Conviction

Jeffrey Dahmer was responsible for the murders of at least seventeen men and boys between 1978 and 1991. His gruesome modus operandi involved luring young men to his apartment, drugging them, and then sexually assaulting and killing them. He also mutilated and dismembered his victims and engaged in necrophilia.

Dahmer’s crimes were finally exposed in July 1991, when one of his intended victims managed to escape and alerted the police. When they arrived at his apartment, they found evidence of his heinous crimes, including human remains and body parts stored in his refrigerator and freezer.

Dahmer was convicted of fifteen counts of murder in 1992 and was sentenced to fifteen consecutive life sentences. He was sent to Columbia Correctional Institution in Wisconsin, where he would meet his fate at the hands of another inmate.

After Dahmer’s conviction, his case became one of the most high-profile and controversial in American criminal history. Many people were shocked and horrified by the extent of his crimes, and there was widespread debate about how such a monster could have gone undetected for so long. Some critics argued that the police and justice system had failed to take Dahmer’s crimes seriously because many of his victims were gay or from marginalized communities.

Despite the controversy surrounding his case, Dahmer’s crimes had a lasting impact on the criminal justice system and the way that serial killers are investigated and prosecuted. His case highlighted the importance of forensic evidence and the need for law enforcement agencies to work together to catch dangerous criminals before they can do more harm.

Who was Christopher Scarver?

Christopher Scarver was a convicted murderer who was serving time in Columbia Correctional Institution for the killing of his former boss and a coworker in 1990. Scarver had a history of violence and mental illness, and he was known to be a difficult and unpredictable prisoner.

During his time in prison, Scarver was involved in several violent incidents, including an attack on serial killer Jeffrey Dahmer in 1994. Scarver used a metal bar to beat Dahmer to death, claiming that he was carrying out God’s will. Scarver was also suspected of killing another inmate, Jesse Anderson, in the same incident.

Inside the Mind of a Serial Killer

Dahmer’s crimes were some of the most barbaric and incomprehensible of our time. He was a diagnosed necrophiliac and a cannibal who sought to prolong his control over his victims, even after death. His actions were driven by a complex combination of psychological and biological factors, including childhood trauma, substance abuse, and mental illness.

Scarver, on the other hand, had a history of paranoid delusions and violence. He had been diagnosed with schizophrenia and was considered a high-risk prisoner. He was known for his volatile temper and had reportedly attacked other inmates and officers in the past.

Despite their different backgrounds and motivations, both Dahmer and Scarver were able to commit heinous crimes while in prison. This raises questions about the effectiveness of the prison system in rehabilitating and preventing violent behavior.

Studies have shown that access to mental health treatment and support can greatly reduce the risk of violent behavior in individuals with mental illness. However, many prisons lack adequate resources and staff to provide these services to inmates.

The Connection between Dahmer and Scarver

According to reports, Scarver and Dahmer had very little interaction before the day of the murder. Scarver was assigned to a work detail with Dahmer and another inmate, Jesse Anderson, on the morning of November 28th, 1994. The three men were left unsupervised while cleaning the prison’s gymnasium.

It was during this time that Scarver attacked both Dahmer and Anderson with a metal bar he had smuggled from the prison weight room. Anderson died from his injuries, while Dahmer was beaten to death with the same weapon.

After the murder, Scarver was found guilty of killing both Dahmer and Anderson and was sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole. Scarver has since claimed that he was acting on God’s orders when he committed the murders and that he believed Dahmer was a devil worshipper.

Despite Scarver’s claims, many experts believe that the motive for the murders was more likely related to Scarver’s mental health issues and his history of violent behavior. Scarver had previously been diagnosed with schizophrenia and had a history of violent outbursts while in prison.

The Brutal Murder of Jeffrey Dahmer in Prison

The details of Dahmer’s death are as gruesome as the crimes he committed. Scarver reportedly beat Dahmer with the metal bar until he was unrecognizable and his head was caved in. He then strangled Dahmer with a towel.

When questioned about the murder, Scarver claimed that he had no specific motive but that he had been angered by Dahmer’s taunts and his perceived indifference to the suffering of his victims. Scarver also stated that he was being controlled by the spirit of his victims and that he had been sent to kill Dahmer by God.

Jeffrey Dahmer was a notorious serial killer who was convicted of murdering 17 men and boys between 1978 and 1991. He was known for his heinous crimes, which included rape, dismemberment, and cannibalism. Dahmer was sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole, but his life was cut short when he was brutally murdered by fellow inmate Christopher Scarver in 1994.

What Motivated Scarver to Kill Dahmer?

The precise motivations behind Scarver’s actions are difficult to pin down. It is clear that he had a history of violent and unpredictable behavior, and that he had been diagnosed with schizophrenia. Some have speculated that Scarver was driven by a desire for revenge or for the notoriety that would come with killing one of America’s most infamous serial killers.

However, Scarver himself has stated that his actions were motivated by Dahmer’s heinous crimes. Scarver was serving a life sentence for murder when he was assigned to work with Dahmer in the prison’s gym. According to Scarver, Dahmer would taunt and mock other inmates, often using food to lure them into his cell where he would then assault and murder them. Scarver claims that he could no longer tolerate Dahmer’s behavior and decided to take matters into his own hands.

Despite Scarver’s claims, some have questioned the validity of his story. They argue that Scarver may have been seeking attention or trying to justify his own violent actions. Regardless of his motivations, Scarver’s attack on Dahmer has become a notorious moment in American criminal history, and has sparked ongoing debates about the ethics of vigilante justice.

Theories and Speculations Surrounding the Murder

There are many theories and speculations surrounding the killing of Jeffrey Dahmer by Christopher Scarver. Some have suggested that Scarver was acting out of revenge for Dahmer’s crimes, while others have proposed that he was seeking attention or hoping to improve his own standing among other prisoners.

There are also those who speculate that Scarver may have been influenced by outside forces, such as extremist religious ideology or a desire to send a message to society at large. However, without clear evidence to support any specific theory, it remains difficult to draw any firm conclusions about Scarver’s motivations.

Despite the lack of concrete evidence, some experts have pointed to Scarver’s history of mental illness and violent behavior as potential factors in the murder. Scarver had previously been diagnosed with schizophrenia and had a history of attacking both inmates and guards. Some have suggested that his mental state may have played a role in his decision to kill Dahmer.

Scarver’s Confession and Statements about the Crime

Scarver has given conflicting accounts of the murder over the years. In one interview, he claimed that he had been sent to kill Dahmer by God and that the other inmates had assisted him in carrying out his mission. In another interview, he stated that he had acted alone and had not planned the attack in advance.

Despite his many statements, Scarver has never provided a consistent or definitive explanation for why he killed Dahmer. Some experts speculate that his erratic behavior and conflicting testimony suggest that he may suffer from dissociative identity disorder or other mental illnesses.

Additionally, Scarver has been known to have a history of violent behavior and was already serving a life sentence for a previous murder when he killed Dahmer. Some have suggested that Scarver may have targeted Dahmer due to the nature of his crimes, as Dahmer was a notorious serial killer who had been convicted of murdering and dismembering 17 men and boys.

The Impact of Dahmer’s Death on Society and Criminal Justice System

The death of Jeffrey Dahmer was a shocking event that had a significant impact on both the public and the criminal justice system. For many, it was a satisfying form of justice for the families of Dahmer’s victims, who had suffered so much at his hands.

However, others criticized the circumstances of Dahmer’s death and called into question the safety of inmates in the prison system. Some experts pointed out that Scarver’s supposed mental illness and history of violence suggested that he should never have been allowed to come into contact with someone like Dahmer in the first place.

Furthermore, Dahmer’s death sparked a renewed interest in the study of serial killers and their psychology. Many researchers and psychologists used Dahmer’s case as a basis for further understanding the minds of serial killers and the factors that contribute to their behavior.

Additionally, the media frenzy surrounding Dahmer’s death brought attention to the issue of sensationalism in news reporting. Some criticized the media for glorifying Dahmer and turning him into a celebrity, while others argued that the media had a responsibility to report on such a high-profile case.

Lessons Learned from the Tragic Case of Jeffrey Dahmer

The case of Jeffrey Dahmer is a reminder of the dangers of untreated mental illness and the need for greater awareness and understanding of these conditions. It also highlights the importance of effective prison reform and the need for adequate resources to be devoted to mental health and rehabilitation programs for inmates.

Furthermore, the case underscores the need for greater public education about the factors that can lead to violent and extreme behavior, and the ways in which society can work to prevent these kinds of tragedies from occurring in the future.

One of the most important lessons we can learn from the case of Jeffrey Dahmer is the importance of early intervention and treatment for mental illness. Dahmer’s behavior and actions were indicative of a severe mental illness, but unfortunately, he did not receive the help he needed until it was too late. This tragedy highlights the need for better access to mental health services and resources, as well as increased efforts to reduce the stigma surrounding mental illness.

The Psychological Effects of Incarceration on Inmates

The case of Jeffrey Dahmer also raises important questions about the psychological effects of incarceration on inmates. Scarver’s violent behavior and erratic statements suggest that he was deeply affected by his time in prison, and that the experience may have exacerbated his underlying mental health issues.

Many experts argue that the harsh conditions of incarceration can cause lasting psychological damage to inmates, reinforcing violent or antisocial behaviors and making it more difficult for individuals to lead normal, healthy lives after their release. This has led to calls for more humane and rehabilitative approaches to incarceration, with a greater focus on mental health initiatives and education and training programs.

Studies have shown that prolonged periods of isolation and confinement can have severe psychological effects on inmates, including depression, anxiety, and even suicidal thoughts. In addition, the lack of access to adequate healthcare and mental health services in many prisons can exacerbate pre-existing conditions and lead to further deterioration of mental health. It is important for policymakers and prison officials to prioritize the mental health and well-being of inmates, not only for their own sake but also for the safety of society as a whole.

The Ethics of Capital Punishment in Light of the Crime

The death of Jeffrey Dahmer raises important ethical questions about the use of capital punishment in the United States. Although Dahmer was never executed for his crimes, Scarver’s murder of Dahmer has sparked debate about the appropriateness of the death penalty for the most severe cases of violent crime.

Many argue that the death penalty is a necessary and appropriate response to individuals like Dahmer, who commit heinous crimes that defy our understanding of human behavior. However, others argue that the death penalty is inherently cruel and inhumane and should be abolished in favor of more humane forms of punishment and rehabilitation.


The case of Jeffrey Dahmer and his brutal murder at the hands of Christopher Scarver is a complex and tragic event that continues to raise difficult questions about crime, punishment, mental health and the responsibility of society to prevent violent behavior.

While the precise motivations behind Scarver’s actions remain unclear, what is clear is that this event highlights the importance of treating mental illness and providing adequate resources for inmates to overcome the psychological effects of incarceration.

Ultimately, the case of Jeffrey Dahmer and his murder by Christopher Scarver serves as a reminder of the profound and lasting impacts of violent crime on individuals, families, and society as a whole.