Jail guard Amara Brown admits to DoorDash delivery for inmate
Guard Amara Brown at Alvin S. Glenn Detention Center is charged with using DoorDash to deliver a meal to an inmate.
17 Jun 2023, Prisons, by
Discover how prison visitation can actually increase the likelihood of reoffending.
Visiting a loved one who is in prison can be a very emotional experience. While it may provide some comfort and support for inmates, recent studies suggest that visitation may actually increase the risk of recidivism. This article delves deep into the impact of visitation on inmate rehabilitation, exploring the link between visitation and reoffending. We also examine the role of family support in reducing recidivism rates and the emotional toll of incarceration on families.
Prison visitation has long been seen as a vital part of the rehabilitation process for inmates. The opportunity to see family members and loved ones can have a positive effect on an inmate’s mental health. It can help alleviate feelings of loneliness, isolation and depression. Visitation has also been seen as a way to maintain family connections and deter inmates from committing further crimes.
However, studies conducted in recent years have suggested that prison visitation may not be as positive as we once thought. In fact, in some cases, it may even increase the risk of recidivism amongst inmates.
One reason for this is that visitation can sometimes bring negative influences into the prison environment. Family members or friends may bring drugs or other contraband into the facility, which can lead to disciplinary action for the inmate and potentially harm their chances of rehabilitation. Additionally, some inmates may become more focused on their relationships outside of prison, rather than on their own personal growth and development.
Research has shown that inmates who receive regular visits from family members are more likely to re-offend upon release than those who don’t have regular visits. While the reasons for this are not entirely clear, some theorists suggest that frequent visits can make the transition back into society harder for the inmate. They may become overly reliant on their family members or may feel overwhelmed by their new responsibilities.
Another possible explanation for this pattern is that inmates who are visited regularly may have stronger ties to criminal lifestyles and negative environments. Moreover, regular visitation may also instill the notion that criminal behavior is accepted or “normalized” within their family circle.
However, it is important to note that not all types of visitation have the same effect on reoffending rates. Studies have shown that visits from religious or community groups, as well as visits that involve educational or vocational training, can actually decrease the likelihood of reoffending. These types of visits provide inmates with a sense of purpose and support, and can help them develop skills that will be useful upon release.
Furthermore, the impact of visitation on reoffending rates may also depend on the length of the inmate’s sentence. Inmates who are serving shorter sentences may be more likely to reoffend regardless of whether they receive regular visits or not, while those serving longer sentences may benefit more from regular visitation as it can help them maintain connections to the outside world and provide a sense of hope for the future.
Despite these concerns, family support has been shown to significantly reduce recidivism rates. In cases where inmates are supported by family members who are able to offer guidance and advice, they are less likely to re-offend. This underscores the importance of family in the rehabilitation process.
For families of inmates, offering support can be a difficult and emotional process. Being separated from a loved one can be emotionally draining, and the worry and uncertainty of what the future holds can be overwhelming. Families may also find it difficult to navigate the various obstacles that come with prison visitation, such as travel expenses and scheduling conflicts.
However, there are programs and resources available to help families support their incarcerated loved ones. Many prisons offer counseling services and support groups for families, as well as assistance with visitation and communication. Additionally, there are non-profit organizations that provide resources and support to families of inmates, such as financial assistance for travel expenses and emotional support.
It’s important to recognize that families of inmates also experience significant emotional stress. The process of incarceration can take a significant toll on family members, with feelings of guilt, shame, and frustration being common. The stigma surrounding incarceration often has a profound effect on how families are viewed by their community.
It’s also worth noting that studies have shown that children of incarcerated parents may face a range of negative outcomes, including poor academic performance and emotional distress. This highlights the importance of supporting the families of inmates in order to break this cycle of intergenerational criminality.
Furthermore, the financial burden of incarceration can also be overwhelming for families. In addition to legal fees and court costs, families may have to cover the costs of phone calls, visits, and even basic necessities for their incarcerated loved one. This can lead to financial strain and even poverty for some families.
Another aspect of the emotional toll of incarceration on families is the strain it can put on relationships. Incarceration can lead to a breakdown in communication and trust between family members, as well as feelings of isolation and loneliness for the incarcerated individual. It’s important for families to have access to resources and support to help them navigate these challenges and maintain healthy relationships.
Despite the concerns regarding visitation, there is still a strong argument to be made for the importance of maintaining family connections for inmates. Visitation programs can play an important role in facilitating these connections. By providing a structured and supportive environment for visits, inmates can maintain their ties to the outside world while also being held accountable for their actions.
Many successful visitation programs incorporate education and counselling into their services, helping to ease the transition back into society and providing the skills and knowledge needed to avoid reoffending. Such programs may be specifically designed to address the needs of the individual inmate, taking into account the unique circumstances that have led to their incarceration.
Furthermore, visitation programs can also have a positive impact on the mental health of inmates. Studies have shown that maintaining family connections can reduce the risk of depression and anxiety among incarcerated individuals. Regular visits from loved ones can provide a sense of hope and motivation, which can be crucial in helping inmates to stay focused on their rehabilitation and eventual reintegration into society.
Another benefit of visitation programs is that they can help to reduce the likelihood of recidivism. By maintaining strong family connections and receiving support and guidance from visitation programs, inmates are more likely to successfully reintegrate into society and avoid returning to a life of crime. This not only benefits the individual inmate, but also has wider societal benefits in terms of reducing crime rates and improving public safety.
The effectiveness of visitation programs can vary widely depending on a range of factors. The frequency and duration of visits, the level of support provided to families, and the specific needs of the inmate are just a few of the factors that can influence the efficacy of the program.
It’s also important to consider the impact of location and accessibility. Prisons located far from the family home or without adequate transportation links can make visitation difficult or impossible. These challenges are often exacerbated for low-income families, who may not have the financial resources to make frequent visits.
Another important factor to consider is the quality of the visitation environment. Visitation areas that are overcrowded, noisy, or lack privacy can make it difficult for families to connect with their loved ones. Additionally, the behavior of prison staff during visitation can have a significant impact on the experience. Staff who are rude, dismissive, or overly strict can create a hostile environment that undermines the positive effects of the program.
Despite these challenges, it’s clear that structured visitation programs can play an important role in reducing recidivism rates. These programs can provide the support and resources needed to help families of inmates navigate the complexities of the criminal justice system.
Moreover, visitation programs can provide an important lifeline to inmates, helping them to stay connected to society and to the people who care about them. By providing a supportive and structured environment for visits, these programs can play an important role in facilitating the rehabilitation process.
Structured visitation programs can also have a positive impact on the mental health of inmates. Studies have shown that regular visits from loved ones can reduce feelings of isolation and depression, which are common among incarcerated individuals. By providing a safe and supportive space for visits, these programs can help to improve the overall well-being of inmates.
Additionally, structured visitation programs can help to strengthen family bonds and relationships. By facilitating regular visits and communication between inmates and their families, these programs can help to maintain important connections that may have been strained or broken due to incarceration. This can have a positive impact on the reentry process, as inmates who have strong support systems are more likely to successfully reintegrate into society.
With advances in technology, there is potential for virtual visitation programs to play a greater role in facilitating family connections. Virtual visitation involves using video conferencing technology to connect inmates with family members who are unable to visit physically. This may be particularly beneficial for families who live far away from the prison or who cannot afford the travel expenses associated with in-person visitation.
While virtual visitation has the potential to improve family connections, it’s important to consider the impact on the rehabilitation process. Studies have suggested that virtual visitation may not have the same positive effects on inmate mental health as in-person visitation, and may even increase the risk of recidivism. Further research is needed to fully understand the benefits and limitations of virtual visitation.
Another potential impact of technology on prison visitation is the use of social media platforms. Some prisons have implemented social media programs that allow inmates to communicate with family members and friends through monitored accounts. This can provide a more immediate and frequent form of communication, but also raises concerns about privacy and security.
Additionally, technology can be used to improve educational and vocational training programs for inmates, which can reduce recidivism rates. Online courses and job training programs can be accessed remotely, allowing inmates to gain valuable skills and knowledge that can help them successfully reintegrate into society upon release.
There are a number of strategies that can be employed to improve the efficacy of visitation programs. One key factor is ensuring that the programs are accessible and inclusive for all families, regardless of their financial situation or location. This may involve providing financial support for low-income families or offering transportation services to help families travel to the prison.
Another key strategy is to provide education and counseling services for both inmates and their families. This can help reduce the stigma surrounding incarceration and provide families with the tools they need to support their incarcerated loved one.
Finally, it’s important to evaluate the effectiveness of visitation programs on an ongoing basis. This can involve collecting feedback from inmates and their families, analyzing recidivism rates, and assessing the impact of specific program components on the rehabilitation process.
One of the key barriers to successful visitation programs is financial insecurity and poverty, which affect millions of families across the United States. Providing economic relief in the form of grants or subsidies may help to reduce the financial burden and make visitation more accessible for low-income families. Additionally, providing transportation services and flexible scheduling may further break down barriers for low-income families grappling with systemic poverty and income inequality.
It’s also important to recognize the role of systemic racism in the criminal justice system and how it impacts visitation opportunities for marginalized communities, including people of color and immigrants. Addressing racial and social inequities in our justice system is a crucial step toward improving visitation programs and promoting rehabilitation for all inmates.
Despite the risks associated with visitation, there is no denying the psychological benefits that can be gained from family connections. Inmates who receive regular visits have reported feeling less isolated and more supported during their incarceration. Visits can provide a reminder of the world outside of prison and can motivate inmates to work towards their rehabilitation.
Furthermore, visits can provide affirmation and positive feedback that helps inmates feel more confident and supported when it comes to exiting prison and reintegrating back into society. While it’s important to be mindful of the risks associated with visitation, it’s equally important to recognize the value and significance of family connections in the rehabilitation process.
The impact of incarceration on families is complex and multifaceted. It can strain relationships and create emotional distance between family members. It can also affect the financial stability of the family, as the loss of a breadwinner can create economic insecurity and financial difficulty.
It’s important for families to have access to resources and support during this time, including educational and counseling services that can provide tools to mitigate and manage the challenges created by incarceration. Prison visitation programs can play an important role in facilitating these connections and helping families to stay connected during and after incarceration.
The stigma surrounding prison visitations can create barriers to participation and access for families of inmates. This stigma has been shown to be particularly acute for families of color and impoverished communities.
It’s important to recognize the importance of prison visitation programs in promoting rehabilitation and reducing recidivism rates. By breaking down the stigma surrounding visitations, we can promote access to these programs for all families, regardless of their background or socioeconomic status.
Ultimately, the key to reducing recidivism rates through visitation programs lies in the adoption of a comprehensive and holistic approach. This approach should include support for families of inmates, education and counseling services, and a focus on improving access and inclusivity for all families.
It’s also important to recognize the unique needs of individual inmates and to develop programs that are tailored to their specific circumstances. By offering support throughout the rehabilitation process, visitation programs can help inmates to successfully reintegrate back into society, avoid recidivism, and build positive, healthy relationships with their families.
While visitation programs may increase the risk of recidivism if not carefully planned and structured, they also play an important role in the rehabilitation process and help families of inmates to navigate the complexities of the criminal justice system. By adopting a comprehensive approach that takes into account the unique needs of individual inmates and their families, we can begin to build a more effective and inclusive system that puts rehabilitation and family connections at the forefront of our justice system.
Guard Amara Brown at Alvin S. Glenn Detention Center is charged with using DoorDash to deliver a meal to an inmate.
Ali Miles, a trans woman, sues NYC for $22 million, alleging mistreatment and discrimination after being placed in a male prison.
South Dakota lawmakers explore shifting responsibility for inmate legal defense fees from counties to the state.